What would you bring if a photographer asked for one thing that mattered to you? A bicycle, a pet, perhaps a collection of rocks? Eva Verbeeck gave young participants a version of that invitation for America’s Girls, On the Edge of a Dream. Their choices give a viewer somewhere specific to begin. An idea of American girlhood formed at a distance meets the people who actually live it.
The sitter helps decide what the image says
In CNN’s interview , Verbeeck describes reaching participants through schools, youth groups and local communities. She invited them to bring a meaningful detail into the sitting. The publisher also notes that some chose to bring no object. That option is part of the invitation: the person can decide which part of herself she wants the camera to meet.
The cover gives that question a familiar setting. Jazmine, an 11-year-old cheerleader, stands in her uniform against a dark wall. The blue bow, trim and white shoes are easy to pick out, while her full figure keeps its own space within the frame. CNN reports that Verbeeck wanted to challenge the adult-coded cheerleader image she knew from popular culture. Here the recognizable role belongs to a particular young person.
Listening is part of the photographic method
Publisher GOST Books describes a six-year analogue project across 28 states, involving more than 400 girls and young women. The book holds 54 images. Between those two scales sits a photographer’s edit: which encounters go together, which differences remain visible and what a reader notices from one page to the next.
This is a question of portrait photography as much as documentary practice. A photographer can choose a camera position, light, and final edit while still giving a subject meaningful control over how she appears. The collaboration does not erase authorship. It makes the relationship between photographer and sitter part of what a reader should understand about the result.
Let a place or outfit carry the sitter’s history
At Kisau Photography , my “My Style. My World. My Story.” theme asks a related question about personal choices within a portrait. In the Akane interview, Kagurazaka is a neighborhood with chapters of her own life attached to it. Her explanation gives two outfits on the same streets different meanings. I publish Kisau, and that relationship is part of why the connection interests me.
The Hong Kong portrait photo essay offers another credited sequence of my Kisau work, with the setting and gesture visible together. The projects have different subjects and forms. Verbeeck works across a national documentary book with young participants. Kisau brings individual stories into fashion and portrait collaborations. A useful connection between them is the space for someone to tell you what a place, garment or object means before you decide what it will mean in your photograph.
The Tim Walker collaboration profile offers a second example of a portrait changing when the people in it bring their own object or history.
For a photographer, try asking about the object before placing it. How does the person use it? What would she want someone to understand about it? The answer may suggest a position or setting you would not have chosen from appearance alone. The camera’s arrangement can then grow from something she has told you.
Look at who appears on the next page
Verbeeck grew up in Belgium with images of American adolescence arriving through music, magazines and television. A portrait invitation offers a way to complicate that ready-made picture. A familiar uniform may enter the frame, but so can a choice with no obvious national symbolism. Looking at the person’s relationship with an object is more revealing than deciding in advance which category she represents.
The 54-picture edit deserves the same attention as an individual sitting. Put two portraits beside each other and a reader starts finding relationships, even when the people never met. Change the next picture and that reading can change again. Verbeeck’s book is a selected sequence of encounters. Its interest lies in those particular people and the connections the edit makes available.
Leave time for an answer to change the picture
With young subjects, the invitation to participate needs room for a real choice. CNN describes an approach through communities where people could join. The option to leave an object at home is a small, concrete part of that flexibility. Publication adds another set of decisions about context and circulation, which cannot be answered simply by looking at a compelling final frame.
Large-format film brings a deliberate pace to the sitting. Verbeeck tells the publisher that the slower process made room for conversation. You can consider how that time might change your own portrait practice without needing to copy the equipment. Leave space to listen before settling the frame, and allow the answer to change the picture you thought you were going to make.
Before a portrait session, leave one part of the plan open for the person arriving. It might be an object, a location or the choice to appear without either. Ask what the choice means, then work out how the frame can make room for it. A detail that looks ordinary to the photographer may be the one that makes the portrait belong to its sitter.
FAQ
Did each participant have to bring an object?
No. Verbeeck invited people to bring something meaningful, but choosing to appear without an object was part of the choice.

